Delirium, dementia and depression — differentiation
3Ds differentiation · Psychiatry / Behavioural
Physician-written · Verified by three sets of doctors · Reviewed November 2026
Bedside summary
The three Ds frequently coexist and are confused in older adults. Delirium is acute, fluctuating and organic; dementia is chronic and progressive; depression (pseudodementia) causes reversible cognitive impairment. Accurate differentiation changes management profoundly, and delirium — a medical emergency — must always be excluded first.
Red flags
- Acute onset with fluctuating consciousness (delirium — medical emergency)
- New focal neurology or recent head injury/falls on anticoagulants
- Rapid cognitive decline with systemic illness
- Suicidal ideation in depressive presentation
- Hypoactive delirium mistaken for depression/dementia
Assessment
Differential diagnosis
- Delirium (acute, fluctuating, altered consciousness)
- Dementia (chronic, progressive, clear consciousness)
- Depression with cognitive impairment (pseudodementia)
- Delirium superimposed on dementia (common and dangerous)
- Other organic cause (hypothyroidism, B12 deficiency, normal-pressure hydrocephalus, subdural)
Investigations
- Cognitive assessment (4AT for delirium, collateral for baseline cognition)
- Bloods: FBC, U&E, LFTs, CRP, calcium, glucose, TFTs, B12/folate
- Urinalysis and septic screen as indicated
- ECG and medication review (anticholinergic burden)
- CT head if focal signs, head injury, anticoagulation or diagnostic uncertainty
Management
- Establish time course and baseline from collateral history (acute vs chronic vs weeks)
- Assess consciousness and attention — impaired/fluctuating suggests delirium
- Apply the 4AT or similar screening tool
- Screen systematically for organic precipitants (infection, drugs, metabolic, retention, pain, constipation)
- Assess mood and biological symptoms for depression
- Treat identified delirium causes; optimise environment and reduce deliriogenic drugs
- Refer for memory assessment if dementia suspected and delirium excluded
- Arrange psychiatric input for depression/pseudodementia
Drugs & doses
Treat the cause — antibiotics, fluids, analgesia, laxatives as appropriate for delirium
Haloperidol — 0.5 mg PO/IM for severe delirium agitation (avoid in Parkinson's/Lewy body); lowest dose, shortest time
Lorazepam — 0.5 mg PO/IM if antipsychotic contraindicated (Parkinson's/Lewy body); max 2 mg/24h in elderly
Sertraline — 25-50 mg PO OD for confirmed depression (initiated with psychiatric guidance)
Disposition
Admit and investigate delirium as a medical emergency; refer suspected dementia to memory services and depression to old-age psychiatry once delirium is excluded — most depression/dementia can be managed in the community with follow-up.
Complications & pitfalls
- Missed delirium with high mortality
- Inappropriate antipsychotics worsening Lewy body dementia
- Untreated depression and suicide
- Prolonged hospital stay and functional decline
- Diagnostic overshadowing
Exam pearls
- Delirium is acute and fluctuates with impaired attention; test attention (months backwards, days of week)
- Hypoactive delirium is easily mislabelled as depression or 'just dementia' — and carries the worst prognosis
- Always get a collateral baseline — you cannot diagnose a change without it
- Depression (pseudodementia) patients often say 'I don't know' rather than confabulate
- Antipsychotics can be lethal in Lewy body dementia (severe sensitivity reactions)
Disclaimer: Educational decision support for qualified clinicians and students — not a substitute for clinical judgement, local protocols or a full drug reference. Confirm every dose and contraindication against your formulary before prescribing.