Capacity assessment & refusal of treatment
Medicolegal · Psychiatry / Behavioural
Physician-written · Verified by three sets of doctors · Reviewed November 2026
Bedside summary
Structured assessment of whether a patient can make a specific decision, and the lawful approach when an unwell patient refuses care. Common, high-stakes ED situation.
Red flags
- Life-threatening condition with refusal
- Fluctuating consciousness (delirium impairs capacity)
- Risk to self or others
Assessment
Differential diagnosis
- Delirium
- Intoxication
- Dementia
- Acute psychosis
- Depression affecting decision-making
Investigations
- Screen for reversible causes affecting cognition (glucose, infection, hypoxia, toxins)
- Collateral history; cognitive assessment
Management
- Assess the four elements: understand, retain, weigh, and communicate the decision
- Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific — reassess as the clinical picture changes
- A capacitous adult may refuse even life-saving treatment
- If lacking capacity: act in best interests (least restrictive); consider IMCA / advance directives
- Use mental-health legislation appropriately for mental-disorder-driven risk; document thoroughly and seek senior/legal advice
Disposition
Depends on the clinical decision; psychiatric liaison and senior/legal input as needed.
Complications & pitfalls
- Harm from untreated illness
- Medicolegal consequences of getting it wrong
Exam pearls
- Capacity is decision- and time-specific — not global
- Always exclude and treat reversible causes of impaired cognition
- Document the assessment and involve seniors early
Assess understand/retain/weigh/communicate; treat reversible causes; act in best interests when capacity is absent.
Disclaimer: Educational decision support for qualified clinicians and students — not a substitute for clinical judgement, local protocols or a full drug reference. Confirm every dose and contraindication against your formulary before prescribing.